Fuelly Forums

Fuelly Forums (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/)
-   Aerodynamics (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/f14/)
-   -   How would someone go about lowering a Geo Metro? (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/f14/how-would-someone-go-about-lowering-a-geo-metro-3948.html)

Peakster 02-25-2007 11:23 AM

How would someone go about lowering a Geo Metro?
 
4 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by MetroMPG (Post 40369)
- reduced ride height (3 inches is often quoted as optimal)

I'm seriously considering to lower my Geo. My old Fiero had a ground clearance of around 4.5 inches (with the tiny P185 70 R13 tires) and wouldn't mind if the Geo was the same.

Attachment 226
VS
Attachment 225

What is the least expensive method of doing so (without throwing out alignment to the tires)?

SVOboy 02-25-2007 11:32 AM

You'll throw out the alignment a bit no matter what...I wouldn't cut your springs, because it will affect the spring rate...you can always buy lowering springs, the GT version might be lower?

You could also try to find other cars with same radius springs and try to find some lower...?

Peakster 02-25-2007 11:58 AM

2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by SVOboy (Post 41870)
...you can always buy lowering springs, the GT version might be lower?

The GT version does appear to be lower, but finding GT springs at a decent price will be difficult.

Waterboy lowered their metro by 2":
Attachment 227

I'd give them an E-mail of how she/he did it, but this member hasn't been online since December 2006. The front wheels seem to be aligned ok, but the rear ones look a bit wonky.

Maybe I should just stop the next lowered vehicle I see on the street and ask them how they did it.

skewbe 02-25-2007 02:21 PM

https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&i...er+cut+&num=25

CoyoteX 02-25-2007 02:24 PM

I cut the springs on my car and have it sitting within 1/2 inch of the bump stops. I am not sure how much it is lowered from factory but probably at least 2 inches or so. It rides much better, the factory springs are way to soft and could use a bit of stiffening.

Peakster 02-25-2007 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coyote X (Post 41885)
I cut the springs on my car and have it sitting within 1/2 inch of the bump stops. I am not sure how much it is lowered from factory but probably at least 2 inches or so.

I guess I could always try finding springs from another Metro, cut them, and try them out. That way if there is a big tire-wear issue, I can always put the originals back on.

If and when I do lower the car, it's going to be a considerable drop (just measured the ride height and it's 9 inches! :eek:). 1/2 inch from bump stops might be in order.

MetroMPG 02-25-2007 04:23 PM

Yeah our gen 4&5 cars are odd in how much ground clearance they have.

Also, the later cars had stiffer springs. I talked to Waterboy (it might have been someone else with a chopped spring mk5) and he said his car is pretty harsh after the chop. If he could undo it, he would have cut less.

It has been said at teamswift that the mk3 cars had softer springs, so you might want to see if you can get a set of those to cut. The ride won't be so brutal afterwards.

Peakster 02-25-2007 04:31 PM

Thank you for the advice MetroMPG!

MetroMPG 02-25-2007 04:36 PM

Sure thing. Might want to verify the spring rate & intergenerational swappability though. Don't believe everything you read ;)

cfg83 02-25-2007 06:19 PM

theclencher -

Quote:

Originally Posted by theclencher (Post 41877)
I'd cut the springs for a mild lowering job but not for a big slam.

I have cut the springs on my Lambo and am very satisfied with the results.

Do a search- this has been hashed out here before.

Here's one :

Best way to do a lowering experiment?
https://www.gassavers.org/showthread.php?t=1776

CarloSW2

Peakster 02-25-2007 08:29 PM

Thanks everyone. From the sounds of everything, it looks like cutting the springs is the easiest way to go. Now figuring out how to cut them is the question. I feel that I should just park the Geo in some highschool shop class and let them go to town (meanwhile forcing me to drive less :D).

Peakster 02-25-2007 09:25 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by theclencher (Post 41965)
I Then I decided how much to cut, then I went to the local metal dealer and he let me use his chop saw for free to cut my springs. A big chop saw is awesome, cuts through them like butter.

Nice! Man, this is going to be one crazy mod. Other drivers are going to think I'm insane!

Attachment 229

*drools* Ok I'll probably not go that low. I still need to get through the snow.

Edit: Actually, I'll probably just chop one inch. Drive around for a while and see how it feels. I can always chop again, but can't go the other way if it's too low.

SVOboy 02-25-2007 09:33 PM

Don't forget to set you toe after you drop. It will probably be slightly out of whack, and it will be the only thing that should affect tire wear (camber won't unless it becomes excessive and castor [caster?] should not be affected).

Peakster 02-25-2007 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SVOboy (Post 41977)
Don't forget to set you toe after you drop. It will probably be slightly out of whack, and it will be the only thing that should affect tire wear.

Ok. I know I've been here for several months now, but what in the heck is a toe of a car? (I'm not mechanically inclined at all & will most likely pay someone else to do this for me) If "toe" means alignment, how would I be able to align the rear wheels?

Edit: Looked up what "toe" means. I'm more concerned about camber for the wheels.

GasSavers_BluEyes 02-26-2007 03:40 AM

The camber will change slightly, but SVO is dead on that toe is the tire killer. Big numbers on the toe in/out mean you will be just dragging the tire sideways across the pavement and that kills them. You can tell toe wear because the edges of the tread will be 'feathered' If you run your hand across the tire clockwise vs counterclockwise it will feel different.

Caster should increase slightly after lowering a strut-equipped car, but caster doesn't affect tire wear really. Plus more caster is typically a good thing unless you are getting double digits.

Definately the best way to lower the vehicle a large amount is with new springs. Cutting them increases the rate slightly, but not NEARLY as much as you need to increase it if you are taking off more than just a bit. A really low car needs to have stiffer springs to keep from hitting the bumpstops all the time because the suspension has less space to absorb the same forces coming in from the road.

hotroddr 02-26-2007 02:56 PM

** Attempt this at your own risk, I accept no responsibility for any injuries or loss as a result of these suggestions**

I have cut the springs on several vehicles, the last of which was my 84 rabbit. It has similar front suspension as a metro I believe(single control arm/macpherson strut). The back however; is a twist beam with a coil over shock. I believe the metros have independent rear suspension, Im not sure whether its a strut/spring combo or what. For the integrated strut spring type suspension most people remove the whole assembly, compress with a spring compressor, dismantle, cut the spring, compress, reassemble, then see if its ok.
I have found that you do not have to use a spring compressor in most cases.
Last time I removed struts I removed the nut at the top of the strut while the car was on the ground. This is the one that goes through the strut mount. I then jacked up the car and the suspension drooped, put the car on jackstands. The spring will completely relax and the strut shaft will come out of the mount. Leave the mount in place on the car unless it is shot, if its bad replace it. A bad mount usually can be identified by a clunking sound whenever you go over bumps. Make sure that the spring is not still compressed before you unbolt the bottom of the strut. If it is you may have parts shooting all over. you can unbolt the bottom of the strut and pull it out now. The spring will be seperate from the strut and is ready to cut. I usually start with 1 coil and usually end up taking another half to whole coil off after that. I would suggest you take a half a coil at a time to make sure you dont lower it too much. If your spring is not a constant diameter spring you cannot cut it and have it stay in place afterwards. If only one end tapers so that is will sit flat in the spring perch cut the end that does not taper. If both ends taper you will have to bend the spring afterward to ensure that it will sit flat on the perch. I heat it up with a torch just enough to soften the metal a half a coil from the end I cut and bend it so it will sit flat using a large wrench. DO NOT QUENCH THE METAL AFTER HEATING. Let it cool as slowly as possible so that is will not become brittle. After this is all done put the spring on the strut and bolt the bottom of the strut in place. Guide the strut shaft back into the mount as you slowly let the car back down. you could also jack the suspension up to compress the spring again, rather than just letting it back down. THIS IS A POTENTIALLY DANGEROUR JOB ATTEMPT AT YOUR OWN RISK

Another method I have used is to jack up one corner at a time till the suspension is completely drooped(tire off the ground). I then pryed the spring out if the perch with a crowbar and cut off a half a coil at a time with a pneumatic cut off disc till I had cut off a coil and a half. I let the spring relax back into place and then muscled it around till it sat correctly in the perch. all 4 corners took about a half hour total.

However you lower the car you will probably have to trim a little bumpstop off if you hit them often or if you can see that there is very little travel left before contacting the bumpstops. trim as little as possible.

Anytime you cut a spring the spring rate will increase slightly

Most production cars have a little bump steer which means that the tires steer in or out as the suspension moves up or down. This means that if you lower it you likely have changed the toe, you either have more toe in or toe out(fronts of tire closer together, farther apart respectively). You will probably have to get an alignment to correct this, or just wear your tires faster.

If you have stock or stock replacement struts you will blow them out quicker when the car is lowered. The best way to control the suspension on a lowered vehicle is with a stiffer shock/strut. There are aftermarket struts/shocks specifically valved for lowered vehicles. You might have more of a bouncy ride if you lower your car too much on stock struts because they are unable to dampen the inputs to the suspension and you now hit the bumpstops more often. If you dont go overboard in lowering on stock shocks/struts you will not have a problem and your handling will likely improve.

It is not a good idea to lower a car more than where the lower control arms are parallel with the ground. If you do you will possibly gain positive camber more easily in suspension travel, and your roll center will be too low. Lower control arms Parallel with the ground is the ride height to shoot for for performance.

Here are a couple lowered cars I have done. Every car is different so cut a half a coil at a time.
a coil and a half front and back
https://memimage.cardomain.net/member...71_20_full.jpg
Coil and a half front and back
https://memimage.cardomain.net/member...96_29_full.jpg
2 coils front, 2" lowering blocks back
https://memimage.cardomain.net/member...556_6_full.jpg
and just for fun, no springs at all, sitting on the ground
https://memimage.cardomain.net/member...587_2_full.jpg

MetroMPG 02-26-2007 03:04 PM

Thanks for that write-up.

PS - Nice collection!

Peakster 02-26-2007 03:22 PM

Excellent info! Thank you.

I'd guess that the 2nd white car is a 1968 Firebird (my dad has a blue one just like it).

hotroddr 02-26-2007 05:59 PM

^^It isnt easy to reshape the spring with it on the strut or car, it is much better to take it off and get it right. If you dont reshape or bend the spring after cutting it if it was originally tapered to sit flat, there is a risk of it slipping off the perch and the car dropping to the bumpstop. This would probably happen at the worst time.

Under no cercumstance should you lower a car by hitting the spring with a torch and relaxing a series of coils. Trust me. Im one of those people that has to find out why you are not supposed to do something if its not immediately obvious why not. I tried heating the springs on the back of my 66 suburban since they were tapered at both ends and could not be cut. It killed the ride. I figured they would have to be replaced anyway to get it lower so I would try heating them and see if it was a myth or not that you are not supposed to just torch the spring. Its true. its kind of cool though, I held the torch to the spring till the truck started slowly dropping, then I pulled it away when It had sank enough. Dont try it though....it will make it way soft and bouncy.

hotroddr 02-26-2007 06:04 PM

I forgot to mention about "indexing" the spring. This is where you orient the spring so that the end of the spring fits correctly on the spring perch. This must be done before the suspension is compressed if you dont use a compressor, or before relaxing the spring if you use a spring compressor. This is necessary to make the car sit as low as possible and also to avoid the possibility of the spring slipping off the perch.

95_corolla 02-26-2007 07:41 PM

I don't know much... but I was thinking of lowering my corolla. You may just try lowering the front and not worry about the rear, easier & cheaper.... maybe just put smaller tires on the back.

Peakster 02-28-2007 08:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by theclencher (Post 42326)
Got stuck in a snowy street with the Lambo (1 1/2"-2" drop) and I'm sure my non-lowered Tempos would have motored right on through there without breaking a sweat as the problem was the floor bottoming out on snow.

Just another thing to keep in mind if you have to rely on your car in less than ideal conditions.

That is a good point. My Geo needed some pushing this winter (probably 3-4 times). It's a bit bizarre to me because the rear-wheel-drive Fiero NEVER got stuck the 3 winters I had it. Maybe it was because the car has ideal weight distribution. The old T-Bird on the the other hand, now that car got stuck a lot! Silly light rear end.

I guess a person could have cut springs for the summer, and slap on the normal ones the same time the winter tires are put on.

skewbe 03-01-2007 05:13 AM

Hmm, I wonder what happens if you put shrader valves on the pressure side of your struts? A sort-of DIY air adjustable shock arrangement.

VetteOwner 03-25-2007 01:52 PM

well whatever you do when u cut them try to keep the metal as cool as possible...and if its hitting the bump stops just cut them off...and trim/cut whatever else hits...i origionally only had about an inch clearance between the axel and the bumpstops on my truck so i cut them off and now i have a good 3-4 inches...i could go even more if i get a notch kit. I really need to lower my truck more (mostly for looks not so much mpg...) thinking about another 2 inches (4/4 drop total)lowest i can go would be a 5/6 drop. but them im riding about a tad less than half a soda can height...deff not good in the winter/roads around here.

Bill in Houston 03-27-2007 05:03 AM

Spring squeezers
 
I meant to post this sooner. These are not the optimum answer, probably, but they will let you easily try out having a lowered car and then undo it if you don't like it, or you need some ground clearance for snow season.
https://www.jcwhitney.com/autoparts/P...003419/c-10101

I thought about trying them on the Element, but it rides pretty rough already. If it was just me driving it and riding in it, I could stand it, but I don't think my family would put up with it.

DRW 03-27-2007 06:24 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by skewbe (Post 42354)
Hmm, I wonder what happens if you put shrader valves on the pressure side of your struts? A sort-of DIY air adjustable shock arrangement.

Like this? I did this to the front and rear struts on my other car before I could afford good shocks. It works OK for small changes and fine tuning, but it's not enough to change a luxury car into a race car.

On my car the front strut shaft has about 1.1 square inches of surface area, so pumping up the shock to 50psi adds 55 pounds to the spring rate. The rear shocks have a small shaft with .37 square inch area, so 50psi in the shock adds 18.5 pounds to the spring. The spring rate of air inside the strut/shock is highly progressive. I measured it when the shock was fully extended and fully compressed. If I had ten psi extended it went up to 45psi when fully compressed. I also noticed the seals seemed to grip tighter and add friction at higher pressures- these shocks obviously were not designed to handle much pressure. I was concerned about durability so I kept the pressure around 20 to 30 psi at stock ride height.

Another area of tuning that opens up with this mod is the shock oil weight and volume. Typical shock/struts use 5 weight oil. Motorcycle shops usually carry heavier weights like 7.5, 10, 15, and sometimes 20weight. Heavier oil compliments stiffer springs since a stiff spring will rebound quicker on a given shock. I had Eibach springs on that car which were about 20% stiffer than stock. 10 and 12.5 weight shock oil worked nicely, 15w was OK, 20w was bad.

Changing oil volume inside the strut/shock has an effect on air capacity and the progressiveness of the airspring. I kept the oil volume the same just to play it safe. I didn't want to blow out seals or crack the JBWeld holding the valvestem in place! :eek:

Peakster 03-27-2007 07:46 PM

I've decided that chopping the springs should be most cost effective (take 1/2 coil at a time off, try them out for a few days, cut more if desired). Now I just need to find a place where I can take the springs to be cut.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:33 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.