Acetone additive : big dissappointment
Well as I said in another thread, I saw an improvement in FC by adding acetone to fuel (around 8% improvement). That was on regular driving. But today I made a better controlled test on a 19,5 km runway that gave no improvement of acetone additive over regular fuel.
Here are the facts of the test conducted on rural roads mostly flat with 3 stops and 2 low gear cornering. Round trip starting at a standstill. Wind NE 20 kmh. I did the runway 5 times, 2 without acetone , 2 with acetone 1:1000 ( 1 part for 1000 parts fuel), these four at low economy speed, and a fifth one at regular speed just for sake of comparison on FE. Car: Smart diesel 800cc turbo 40HP. Pavement: dry even under little drizzle Temperature : 5?C covered. Speed: Slow economy speed around 60-65 kmh. Load: avg around 40 tail wind and around 50 head wind. Acceleration: Load around 60 (or 70 going uphill). Measuring tool : Scangage 2 Here are the results: Without acetone additive: 1st run: 2,3 li/100 avg speed 57 kmh. 2nd run: 2,2 li/100 avg speed 55 kmh. With acetone (1:1000): 3rd run: 2,3 li/100 avg speed 55 kmh. 4th run: 2,2 li/100 avg speed 55 kmh. With acetone regular speed (no comparaison here): 5th run : 3,2 li/100 avg speed 70 kmh. |
it might be because its a diesel anyone else think so?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Well we'll see later with another test ( the last one) when my tank will be clean of acetone. Next one will be done on a longer run, and at higher speed. A few doubts persist : The first one, last time I didn't see improvement on the scanguage but 8% improvement at the end of the tank with pen & paper calc. Second doubt, maybe the acetone used today was too old, I mean pre-mix last fall with diesel. I will try to find out later..... |
I don't know what the gig with Acetone is. I don't know if it's because it's diesel or not. What I do know is I tried it with a Honda civic and I didn't see any measurable or noticible improvement.
One problem I have encountered is that with out better tools than my gas tank and filling, it is pretty tough to get a real good measurement over a short period of time. Their is enough variations from one fill to another, to see improvements and then some of them, like acetone, seem to not be repeatable over a longer period of time. |
Ya, my individual tanks bounce around a lot. Even a three-point moving average of the FE numbers bounces around a lot. Gotta get a SGII.
|
Quote:
|
Diesel was the culprit
Ya, I also think it was the diesel fuel. Acetone only works with gasoline operated engines. Also, the combustion process is totally different when gasoline and diesel are compared.
|
All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:05 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.