Fuelly Forums

Fuelly Forums (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/)
-   General Maintenance and Repair (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/f10/)
-   -   light battery? (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/f10/light-battery-6058.html)

McPatrick 09-13-2007 06:31 AM

lightweight battery?
 
I am looking to replace the battery in my 92 VX. In times past I would go for a heavy duty battery, but now I am wondering about the weight. Does anyone know of a good battery (brand) that will work good in the VX and is still one of the lighter ones on the market?

McPatrick 09-13-2007 06:55 AM

While doing some surfing I came across these links:

https://www.iwsti.com/forums/showthread.php?t=83272

https://forums.vwvortex.com/zerothread?id=2353060

They are both using a lightweight DEKA battery which is only $60 and weighs only 11.5 lbs! Which saves you like 20 lbs on a regular battery. The only thing is that you have to make some kind of mount to be able to attach a battery that small onto your original battery mount. Anyone handy with machining? I am sure more members would like to have this battery!

GasSavers_TomO 09-13-2007 07:16 AM

With a battery like that and the way that the Civic's battery tie down is....you should be able to go to an autoparts store near you, get a universal battery hold down (the threaded "J" hook style) that has the threads going down far enough (like one for a lawn tractor battery) and just install the new, shorter "J' hooks in the OEM position tight enough to hold the smaller battery in place.

I may be going this route come winter time when my 3 year old battery might die. Then again it might make it through this winter as well as it's not showing any sign of dying anytime soon. Realistically on my VX the only thing the battery does is starts the car, then powers the ignition and radio during the summer as the climate control fan is off all summer and only on the first setting during winter. The radio never gets turned up at all, just loud enough to hear.

mrmad 09-13-2007 07:59 AM

You could try the lawnmower battery shown in this thread. $25 at Wally World

https://www.gassavers.org/showthread....hlight=battery

McPatrick 09-13-2007 08:14 AM

Thanks Tom and Mrmad. I went to California for two weeks and when I came back the battery turned out to be totally empty. I jumpstarted it, drove a pretty good distance with it, but the next day..nothing, not even a click from the starter, so I think I have a battery problem. Either that or an alternator problem. Not being mechanically inclined I wonder how I can get this checked without having to then buy from a battery/tire place. Seeing as this battery is only $60 I may just put it in and if that doesn't do the trick i will know it is the alternator :)

I am not using the AC myself either, but the again it's not functional right now hehehe. Havn't got any winter experience with the heater yet.
While in California I saw at a family member of my wife's a solar cell in the back catching rays and thus recharging the battery while the car sits. The solar cell weighs virtually nothing. It's like a small black carpet laying in the back.

trebuchet03 09-13-2007 09:11 AM

Or you have a short that's killing the battery overnight ;)

mrmad 09-13-2007 09:17 AM

Though it is likely a dead battery, did you check to see how clean the battery terminals were? They often get small amounts of corrosion between the terminal and the battery cable which prevents enough current to start. Though not as often, there also could corrosion on where the + cable connects to the starter.

brucepick 09-13-2007 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by McPatrick (Post 72107)
...Not being mechanically inclined I wonder how I can get this checked without having to then buy from a battery/tire place...

Maybe I can encourage you to become just slightly mechanically inclined. Testing to see if its the battery or instead a problem with alternator is not toooo difficult.

You'll need a voltmeter or - more commonly seen - a multitester. A multitester includes a voltmeter plus other goodies, usually a continuity tester and an ohmmeter (measures resistance). Can be had for as little as about $10 at big box stores; coffee or fast food on the way to a shop for "free" testing can cost nearly as much as that!

You need access to the two terminals on the battery: + and -. Sometimes there's a plastic shield over the + terminal so you need to pop it out of the way for testing.

With the engine off, put the + (red) probe of the tester on the battery + terminal and the tester's - probe on the battery's - terminal. Tester should read maybe 12-12.5 volts. The exact voltage isn't that important but you want to see it go up when you start the car, which causes the alternator to run.

With engine idling, put the tester probes on the same terminals as before. Tester should read anywhere between 13 - 14.5 volts with engine idling. You should redo the test again (third time now!)after turning on a bunch of electrical stuff: headlights, fog lights if you have them, cabin fan on full blast with vents open so the air has someplace to go. That would be enough to make the alternator do some work.

As long as the alternator can put out 13 - 14 volts with those things running then you're pretty safe assuming it's able to do it's job, and can supply enough current to charge the battery while still running all your stuff. If alt is doing it's job, that would mean the problem is in in all likelyhood in the battery.

On the other hand if you're only getting 12.5 volts or less (with car and accessories running) then it looks like the alt is not doing its job.

I'm going with IF the alt looks good, then assume the problem is the battery.

I'ts possible that if the alt looks good the problem is not the battery but instead the starter motor is bad, but that's less likely. It's reasonable to replace the battery if the alt tests as OK.

However if you want to cover yourself and not risk buying a new battery in case the starter is bad, you can get a shop to test the starter. They'll need an ammeter (tester) that reads via a sensor clamped over your battery's + cable. Not hard to do but the tester costs more than $10 so you probably won't get your own.

Hope I didn't confuse you. Testing the alternator/battery using a $10 multitester is pretty doable. And it can come in handy for other things too.

Danronian 09-13-2007 11:30 AM

Though pricier, I've heard these batteries perform great, and some are also very lightweight.

https://www.odysseybatteries.co.nz/Batteries.html

Telco 09-13-2007 12:26 PM

Actually, DO worry about tiedown, a hard brake can force the battery to move, and it may move into contact with metal. An otherwise minor incident can turn into a battery exploding under the hood. You can get a tiedown kit that uses a plate with a couple of really long bolts to hold the battery in place, just drill holes in the battery tray, install the bolts, then clamp on the tiedown.

Some parts stores have electrical system testers that will tell you what is wrong with the vehicle. They will roll the unit out and do the test for you for free, no obligation to actually buy from them. If the battery is going dead though, I suggest replacing the alternator and battery as a unit. Trying to charge a dead battery can blow the diodes in the alternator, which then will not charge the new battery. Can turn into a vicious circle. If you are not mechanically inclined, a good mechanic's shop is where you need to turn to for this. Either that or take a case of beer by your friendly neighborhood gearhead.

McPatrick 09-13-2007 03:38 PM

I would love to get a bit more mechanically inclined and I am gonna buy a voltmeter tonight and start on the VX tomorrow following your instructions Bruce!

VetteOwner 09-13-2007 04:50 PM

or could just take the car to autozone (or just about any autoparts store nowadays) and they test the battery and alternator for free and will instantly tell you if either one is good/bad... takes 15 seconds!

but if you want to learn (good stuff to know) then by all means do it! but if you dont have time/need your car for work, autozone or the like is there to test too.

btw your battery just died on its own probably because of parasidic drains(ecm uses a bit to keeps its memory, radio memory, etc) and if you have a defective trunk light or glove box light switch so its staying on all the time that will kill a battery within a week or so...


btw i doubt most lawn tractor batteries usually dont have enough amps to start the car. the ones ive seen put out anywhere between 150-300 amps. your starter could very well take 200-500amps to start. its not good for the battery to almost completly discharge and then recharge every time you start the car (also hard on the alternator)

saveing 5-10 lbs by using a smaller battery i cant see making any difference on a 3000lb car... might as well remove the carpet headliner and door pannels because they weigh more than the battery itself!

mrmad 09-13-2007 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VetteOwner (Post 72202)

btw i doubt most lawn tractor batteries usually dont have enough amps to start the car. the ones ive seen put out anywhere between 150-300 amps. your starter could very well take 200-500amps to start. its not good for the battery to almost completly discharge and then recharge every time you start the car (also hard on the alternator)

saveing 5-10 lbs by using a smaller battery i cant see making any difference on a 3000lb car... might as well remove the carpet headliner and door pannels because they weigh more than the battery itself!

I was surprised to see people trying lawn tractor batteries, but considering they are putting these batteries in Integras with larger, higher compression engines, it looks like it may work on a Civic/CRX/or Metro sized engine. Might not be a good idea if you don't live in the Sun belt as it may have problems starting on a 20 below morning, and the car probably couldn't be used to jump start other cars, but when my battery dies, I'm going to give it a shot. I'm going to do this to save $ over the cost of the regular battery more then to save weight, plus on my Honda, it will give more room for my intake.

thisisntjared 09-13-2007 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmad (Post 72106)
You could try the lawnmower battery shown in this thread. $25 at Wally World

https://www.gassavers.org/showthread....hlight=battery

:thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: you beat me to it. i had a lawnmower battery in my civic for 2 years, then i crashed it... chances are i will put that battery in my current civic when its battery dies...

it weighed 12 lbs when the oem unit was over twice that. more weight savings than a cf hood.

Danronian 09-13-2007 08:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Telco (Post 72131)
Actually, DO worry about tiedown, a hard brake can force the battery to move, and it may move into contact with metal. An otherwise minor incident can turn into a battery exploding under the hood. You can get a tiedown kit that uses a plate with a couple of really long bolts to hold the battery in place, just drill holes in the battery tray, install the bolts, then clamp on the tiedown.

This is true... The battery that came in my VX is too tall for the factory tie-down, and my replacement has been a bungee cord around the battery and tray. Now I see this as a minor threat during an accident. :(

pyramid_head 09-13-2007 08:58 PM

Lookie what i found. I know it's old, but I hope it's some use to you guys out there.

https://www.stealth316.com/2-dynabatt.htm

VetteOwner 09-14-2007 10:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmad (Post 72230)
I was surprised to see people trying lawn tractor batteries, but considering they are putting these batteries in Integras with larger, higher compression engines, it looks like it may work on a Civic/CRX/or Metro sized engine. Might not be a good idea if you don't live in the Sun belt as it may have problems starting on a 20 below morning, and the car probably couldn't be used to jump start other cars, but when my battery dies, I'm going to give it a shot. I'm going to do this to save $ over the cost of the regular battery more then to save weight, plus on my Honda, it will give more room for my intake.


well a normal auto abttery you can get for $40 on the cheap end. AND you dont have to go cutting cables to put in new terminals...


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.