Fuelly Forums

Fuelly Forums (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/)
-   General Maintenance and Repair (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/f10/)
-   -   Who replaced his LAF sensor (O2 sensor, Civic Vx)? (https://www.fuelly.com/forums/f10/who-replaced-his-laf-sensor-o2-sensor-civic-vx-6713.html)

VEI 11-12-2007 10:13 AM

Who replaced his LAF sensor (O2 sensor, Civic Vx)?
 
I am trying to get information about a possible relationship between a defective LAF sensor and a malfunction in "lean burn" :(


So, I have three questions :

Why have you replaced this LAF sensor?

Have you seen a difference in "lean burn", after replacement of this sensor? (Does the engine seems to work better in "lean burn", or not?)

Do you have a response time when you accelerate at low load and low RPM (with old / new sensor) ?


Thanks ;)

Danronian 11-12-2007 10:41 AM

I have driven two different VXs now with recently replace sensors. Both have the same "response delay" and get about the same mileage now.

I think a good rule-of-thumb for the LAF is not to replace it until you are getting poor mileage or you have a CEL for it being faulty. They just cost too much to warrant replacing them for any other reason.

Matt Timion 11-12-2007 11:28 AM

I just replaced mine, but don't have a baseline for mileage. Hell, I don't even know when I enter lean burn... Would be nice if a lean burn light came built in.

VEI 11-12-2007 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danronian (Post 81716)
Both have the same "response delay"

Is this exactly the same problem as me?
->
Quote:

Originally Posted by VEI
Here is a example :
https://fr.youtube.com/watch?v=IiTz8jA7fWM
(It is a climb). I push slowly on the pedal but the car doesn't accelerate, there are some small hesitations. Suddenly, with the same constant pressure, the car accelerates faster.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danronian (Post 81716)
I think a good rule-of-thumb for the LAF is not to replace it until you are getting poor mileage or you have a CEL for it being faulty. They just cost too much to warrant replacing them for any other reason.

Yes, it?s true.
But, sometimes, I have the CEL (5 times a year).
And I think that my ?response delay? is more brutal than before.
I have controlled a lot of sensors (MAP, TPS, LAF), ignition, fuel filter, ... All seems to be OK.
So, I don?t if I must buy a new LAF sensor.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Matt Timion (Post 81728)
I just replaced mine, but don't have a baseline for mileage.

Ok, but when you drive at low load and low RPM, is there a difference with the new sensor?
Is it more pleasant to drive in these conditions?

1993CivicVX 11-12-2007 02:17 PM

VEI YOUR LAF IS NOT WORKING PROPERLY AND NEEDS TO BE REPLACED.

Your lag and stutter is NOT normal lean burn operation. Your car is exhibiting classic symptoms for a bad o2 sensor. No two ways around it. What Danronian was describing was normal lean burn operation which is a fairly subtle stumble upon acceleration, but nothing like what you are describing. Hope that clears it up! You need a new o2 sensor.

When you replace your o2 sensor, your car will no longer do the sudden power surge you have described. My car was doing this before I replaced mine. And it sounds like mine was not as bad as yours and yet I noticed a big difference with the new o2 sensor. You will notice a VERY big difference with a new o2 sensor. Where you should be putting your energy now is figuring out where you are going to get your new o2 sensor. Because they are expensive and not all work properly. Good luck! Wish I could steer you in the right direction but I really don't know where to point you since you are in Belgium! You could try the $79 one I bought, but seems like a bit of a gamble.

VEI 11-13-2007 06:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1993CivicVX (Post 81757)
VEI YOUR LAF IS NOT WORKING PROPERLY AND NEEDS TO BE REPLACED.

I know your opinion. But I would have several answers, several opinion before make a choice.

Ok, you have not this problem with your new sensor, but sometimes, you have the CEL. Your AFR is perhaps a litle diff?rent, more rich. I don't know.

It's difficult for me to explain my problem.
With the new exhaust manifold (no cat.), the accelerator response is different. The "response delay" is more "brutal".
But before, with d15z1 exhaust, I think I already had a "response delay" and some hesitations in lean burn. (More that when I bought the car).

Maybe I am crazy. It is possible that this is normal. I don't know.

GasSavers_TomO 11-13-2007 06:45 AM

I agree with 1993CivicVX, replacing your LAF would be the first step, especially since you've been getting the CEL code for the LAF. That is your computer telling you that the LAF isn't working properly.

Might I suggest that you de-carbon the engine as well. See if your local Honda dealer has the Top Engine Treatment (basically seafoam) or use seafoam. There is a link on how to use the seafoam/de-carbonizer in the VX links in my signature. Do that right before you replace your LAF and install your Catalytic Converter. That will help with the stumble.

Have you cleaned your EGR and EGR ports? If not, this can cause some stumbling on acceleration as well. There is also a How-To in the VX links as well.

You should also think about getting a replacement Catalytic Converter just for emissions sake. To save money you can get an aftermarket one for a regular civic and have a muffler shop, or yourself, install it after the exhaust manifold.

Once you've done all that you should be good.

Danronian 11-13-2007 07:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81893)
I agree with 1993CivicVX, replacing your LAF would be the first step, especially since you've been getting the CEL code for the LAF. That is your computer telling you that the LAF isn't working properly.

Might I suggest that you de-carbon the engine as well. See if your local Honda dealer has the Top Engine Treatment (basically seafoam) or use seafoam. There is a link on how to use the seafoam/de-carbonizer in the VX links in my signature. Do that right before you replace your LAF and install your Catalytic Converter. That will help with the stumble.

Have you cleaned your EGR and EGR ports? If not, this can cause some stumbling on acceleration as well. There is also a How-To in the VX links as well.



I agree, sounds like some sound advice to getting your z1 working smoothly. While you're at it, I would also pull off the IACV (on the back of the intake plenum, facing the firewall) and make sure it's not clogged by spraying some intake cleaner into it. With that cleaned out, and the above suggestions put into place, the only other thing it could possibly be is that your timing is off.

If you have a timing light, you might want to check that and adjust it according to Honda's recommendation. The timing being off can also make your car stumble when accelerating.

edit:
With your different exhaust manifold, where is your LAF mounted? If it is too far away from the exhaust ports, the sensor might be taking too long to heat-up and stay warm, making it read incorrectly. I know on some aftermarket headers they have the 02 mounted behind the motor. For the LAF, I think this wouldn't be an ideal location for it at all.

GasSavers_TomO 11-13-2007 08:27 AM

Dan, thanks for adding in the IACV cleaning, I forgot about that.

The LAF is located at the collector just about 7-8inches down from where the OEM manifold would've had it located. Shouldn't be a big factor since it's still close enough and reading all the ports. Besides, that is what the heater circuit is for in the LAF as well. ;)

VEI 11-13-2007 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81893)
Might I suggest that you de-carbon the engine as well. See if your local Honda dealer has the Top Engine Treatment (basically seafoam) or use seafoam.

It?s very difficult to find this kind of treatment in Belgium.
And they often have a bad reputation.
Sometimes, this can be bad for a old engine. This can cause a loss of sealing (The carbon can maintain compression).

I have tried this product last year : https://www.wynns.be/product.aspx?nav...4&p=55964&l=EN


Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81893)
Have you cleaned your EGR and EGR ports?

Yes I have cleaned the EGR.
https://img102.imageshack.us/img102/7292/04fg6.jpg
https://img297.imageshack.us/img297/248/01ps1.jpg

During one week, I have drove without EGR. But no difference.
https://img265.imageshack.us/img265/3706/03fh8.jpg

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81893)
You should also think about getting a replacement Catalytic Converter just for emissions sake.

Last year, I have passed the pollution tests successfully.



Quote:

Originally Posted by Danronian (Post 81896)
I would also pull off the IACV (on the back of the intake plenum, facing the firewall) and make sure it's not clogged by spraying some intake cleaner into it.

I have checked the IACV. It?s seems to be clean.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danronian (Post 81896)
If you have a timing light, you might want to check that and adjust it according to Honda's recommendation. The timing being off can also make your car stumble when accelerating.

I have checked this. It?s good.
https://img143.imageshack.us/img143/4268/02ov9.jpg

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danronian (Post 81896)
With your different exhaust manifold, where is your LAF mounted? If it is too far away from the exhaust ports, the sensor might be taking too long to heat-up and stay warm, making it read incorrectly.

Before :
https://img175.imageshack.us/img175/1866/co02rz8.jpg

Now :
https://img175.imageshack.us/img175/6222/co08yj7.jpg

GasSavers_TomO 11-13-2007 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VEI (Post 81917)
Yes I have cleaned the EGR.

That is good that you have cleaned the EGR, now have you cleaned the EGR ports?
https://users.adelphia.net/~hagakure9.../EgrPorts1.jpg

Quote:

Originally Posted by VEI (Post 81917)
I have checked this. It’s good.
https://img143.imageshack.us/img143/4268/02ov9.jpg

That looks like it's the 12° timing mark (lights up when using a timing light to check timing) What does the timing look like when you check the TDC (Top Dead Center) mark against the TDC mark on the cam gear?

VEI 11-13-2007 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81920)
That is good that you have cleaned the EGR, now have you cleaned the EGR ports?

No, it seemed clean.
And I have the same problem when EGR is DISCONNECTED !




Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81920)
That looks like it's the 12? timing mark (lights up when using a timing light to check timing) What does the timing look like when you check the TDC (Top Dead Center) mark against the TDC mark on the cam gear?

I don't understand your question.
Red mark = 16?
Black mark = TDC (0?), first cylinder.

GasSavers_TomO 11-13-2007 02:43 PM

^^^ok, there are two different things to check when you "check timing".

TDC is the black mark....when that mark is in the pointer, is the TDC mark on the Camshaft pulley at the TDC mark on the inside of the upper timing belt cover?
https://www.we-todd-did-racing.com/we...NDE%3D.jpg

The other way of checking timing is to have the car running and see what the ignition timing is set at. That is when you use a timing light and look at the pulley to see where the timing mark is at. Like the picture you posted.

I hope that makes sense to you. Let me know if it doesn't.

How did you check the EGR ports? Did you remove the EGR plugs in the intake manifold and check?

1993CivicVX 11-13-2007 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by VEI (Post 81891)
I know your opinion. But I would have several answers, several opinion before make a choice.

Ok, you have not this problem with your new sensor, but sometimes, you have the CEL. Your AFR is perhaps a litle diff?rent, more rich. I don't know.

It's difficult for me to explain my problem.
With the new exhaust manifold (no cat.), the accelerator response is different. The "response delay" is more "brutal".
But before, with d15z1 exhaust, I think I already had a "response delay" and some hesitations in lean burn. (More that when I bought the car).

Maybe I am crazy. It is possible that this is normal. I don't know.

I don't think it is possible it is normal. I think no one has replied to that comment because I think the opinion of everyone else is also that it is not normal. It's wishful thinking my friend in lieu of a $320 fix to your problem. Granted I don't know much about cars, but the little I've picked up about my car on this forum leads me to believe there is little other recourse for you in the matter of your stumble/power lag/power surge issues upon acceleration. I can also say that with my car the problem was worse the lower the RPM, which seems to be true for you as well (at 3900RPM you said the problem was not present) I did have the same problem as you. And through the same advice the people here are giving you, I applied to my own car and the problem was fixed. If you search through the forums you'll find other VX owners who had similar problems fixed by replacing their old o2 sensors. o2 sensors do not always throw a CEL when they are not performing at their best and could use replacing. My car was not giving me a CEL when I replaced the o2 sensor, and yet the o2 sensor was the main culprit to the problem. You may want to try www.honda-tech.com to see if you can elicit a different opinion over there, tho.

The replacement of the o2 sensor had the largest positive effect for my car. The right spark plugs also had a big effect for improving the stumble problem. And I think the other things mentioned can't hurt and may help with that specific problem. Anyway, if I come across a little brusque, I don't mean to be rude (look at my title, I sometimes have a hard time being polite) I am trying to help you. Or at least save you some time.

One more thing: it seems that the life span of the o2 sensors is around 170,000 miles, give or take a few 10k. Your car has around 165,000? Basically, there is no indication that your o2 sensor might be fine, and lots of indication that it needs replacing. Namely the CEL, the bad stumble/power lag/surge and the fact that nothing else you have tried has fixed the problem. Anyway, I suppose you can't be too certain about something when it's as expensive as the o2 sensor to fix.

VEI 11-14-2007 09:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81951)
^^^ok, there are two different things to check when you "check timing".

TDC is the black mark....when that mark is in the pointer, is the TDC mark on the Camshaft pulley at the TDC mark on the inside of the upper timing belt cover?

The other way of checking timing is to have the car running and see what the ignition timing is set at. That is when you use a timing light and look at the pulley to see where the timing mark is at. Like the picture you posted.

I hope that makes sense to you. Let me know if it doesn't.

Ok, now I understand what is ?timing?. The word is completely different in French :o
I was thinking about ignition.

Yes, the marks are correct and I have checked my ignition timing (my picture).

But I must replace my timing belt (normally next month).

Quote:

Originally Posted by TomO (Post 81951)
How did you check the EGR ports? Did you remove the EGR plugs in the intake manifold and check?

I have checked under the EGR valve and no carbon.
But, I have the same problem (lag) when the EGR valve is disconnected. So, I think that EGR is good.

Sigifrith 11-14-2007 08:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Matt Timion (Post 81728)
I just replaced mine, but don't have a baseline for mileage. Hell, I don't even know when I enter lean burn... Would be nice if a lean burn light came built in.

Or if some smart member could design a circuit to turn on an idiot light when in lean burn.

dogncatboy 11-15-2007 04:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sigifrith (Post 82244)
Or if some smart member could design a circuit to turn on an idiot light when in lean burn.

This idiot would buy one!

GasSavers_TomO 11-15-2007 06:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sigifrith (Post 82244)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matt Timion (Post 81728)
Would be nice if a lean burn light came built in.

Or if some smart member could design a circuit to turn on an idiot light when in lean burn.
Quote:

Originally Posted by dogncatboy (Post 82279)
This idiot would buy one!


I'm working on it soon, it's on my list of things.

Danronian 11-15-2007 06:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sigifrith (Post 82244)
Or if some smart member could design a circuit to turn on an idiot light when in lean burn.

That would be nice. :D

1993CivicVX 11-15-2007 01:03 PM

That would be pretty sweet TomO. I'm assuming at this point that I'm in lean burn whenever the pedal is feather footed, and I'm out of lean burn when I feel that little power kick and the throttle won't give more power.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:06 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.