I replaced my old Honda Hornet 2005 with a new Honda Hornet 2009 and now I'm having issues pulling up data on a particular bike because it keeps defaulting to the old one.
Looks like you hit a bug in our system. The URL is supposed to increment as you add the exact same model, but that wasn't happening for you for some reason. I'll need to track that down.
In the meantime, I fixed up your URLs so you should be set.
I just deleted the duplicate bike and renamed the other two to how they were before, and the system changed the links back to the same thing again. LOL